Beef

Ribeye steak with smashed potatoes, peppercorn sauce and roasted slaw

Fire-seared ribeye, crispy smashed potatoes and creamy peppercorn sauce, with a colourful roasted slaw. Proper steak-night business.

1 hr 30MediumServes 2 generous servings
Jump to recipe
Ribeye steak with smashed potatoes, peppercorn sauce and roasted slaw ready to serve

Right. Steak and potatoes, but absolutely no beige behaviour. We're talking ribeye with a proper crust, smashed potatoes with crunchy edges and enough peppercorn sauce to drag every last bite through. The roasted slaw brings the colour. Carrot, parsnip, Brussels sprouts and red cabbage get a blast of heat with rosemary and thyme, then a sharp splash of cider vinegar. Rich steak needs that little kick.

Prep
25 min
Cook
1 hr 5
Total
1 hr 30
Serves
2 generous servings
Difficulty
Medium
BBQ
Kettle BBQ
Fire setup
Two zone
BBQ temp
220°C
Internal temp
55°C
Rest
8 min

You’ll need

FOR THE STEAK

FOR THE SMASHED POTATOES

FOR THE ROASTED SLAW

FOR THE PEPPERCORN SAUCE

The cook

  1. Step 1SORT THE FIRE

    Set up a large kettle BBQ for two-zone cooking, with charcoal banked on one side and a clear indirect zone on the other. Aim for 220°C with the lid closed. You'll need two shallow metal trays that fit over the indirect zone without blocking airflow; use a 220°C oven for the vegetables if space is tight. Pat the steaks dry, salt generously and keep refrigerated while you start the potatoes.

  2. Step 2BOIL AND SMASH

    Put the potatoes in a saucepan, cover with cold salted water and bring to the boil. Simmer for 15–20 minutes until a knife slides through easily. Drain and leave to steam-dry for 5 minutes. Place on a metal tray and press each potato down to roughly 1.5 cm thick with the base of a mug. Keep them in one piece, but give those edges a proper crumple.

  3. Step 3GET THE POTATOES CRISP

    Drizzle the smashed potatoes with their oil, working it underneath as well as over the tops. Season with salt and pepper. Roast over indirect heat, lid closed, for 35–40 minutes, turning carefully after 20 minutes. You're after golden undersides and crisp, ragged edges, not pale little cushions.

  4. Step 4ROAST THE SLAW

    Once the potatoes have had 10 minutes, toss the carrot, parsnip, sprouts and cabbage with the rosemary, thyme, oil, salt and pepper. Spread across the second tray in a shallow layer. Roast indirectly for 20–25 minutes, tossing halfway through, until tender with browned edges and a little bite. Toss with the cider vinegar, taste and adjust the seasoning. Keep warm.

  5. Step 5BUILD THE SAUCE

    While the vegetables roast, melt the butter in a small saucepan over a medium hob heat. Add the shallot and soften for 3–4 minutes without browning. Stir in the crushed peppercorns for 30 seconds, then add the stock. Simmer for 5–7 minutes until reduced by roughly half. Add the cream and Worcestershire sauce, then simmer gently for 3–5 minutes until it coats the back of a spoon. Taste before adding salt. Keep warm over a very low heat.

  6. Step 6SEAR THE RIBEYE

    When the vegetables are nearly ready, pat any surface moisture from the steaks and rub with the oil. Put them over the direct heat and sear for 1–2 minutes per side, then keep turning every minute until deeply browned. Use tongs to hold the fatty edges against the grill too. Allow roughly 6–10 minutes in total, moving to the indirect zone if the crust is ready before the centre. Probe from the side into the middle, avoiding fat pockets; pull at 52–53°C for a final medium-rare temperature of about 55°C after resting.

  7. Step 7REST, DON'T FIDDLE

    Rest the steaks on a warm plate for 8 minutes, loosely covered with foil rather than tightly wrapped. This gives the heat time to even out without steaming the crust. These medium-rare temperatures are for whole-cut steaks with every exterior surface thoroughly seared; follow the pack's cooking instructions for mechanically tenderised steaks. Finish crisping the potatoes during the rest if needed.

  8. Step 8PILE IT UP

    Stir any resting juices into the peppercorn sauce and loosen with a splash of water if it has thickened too much. Divide the smashed potatoes between warm plates. Slice the ribeye across the grain and lay it over the potatoes, then spoon over the sauce. Add a generous pile of roasted slaw alongside. Keep some potato edges clear of sauce — you've earned that crunch.

Set your fire

  • Kettle BBQ
  • Two zone
  • 220°C

Technique: Direct grilling, Indirect cooking, Roasting. Cook to 55°C internal. Rest for 8 min.

Ben Forte at the grill

Join the BBQFORTE club.

Fresh recipes, ridiculous ideas and everything worth cooking over fire — straight from me.